Skip to content

Welcome to the new Fahrney's Pens! ✍️

As we elevate the new experience, we continue to enhance products and brand selections.

If a link has moved or a favorite item is missing, our search bar may find it for you.

Planning Your Holiday Shopping?  See Our Holiday Shipping Details for Important Deadlines, Delivery Options, and Holiday Closures.

Planning Your Holiday Shopping?

See Our Holiday Shipping Details for Important Deadlines, Delivery Options, and Holiday Closures.

Collection: Gifts Under $250

Compare (0/6)

1070 products

Amodex Ink & Stain Remover Pocket/Travel Size, 0.5 oz

Amodex Ink & Stain Remover Pocket/Travel Size, 0.5 oz

Regular price $7.00
Sale price $7.00 Regular price $8.50 Save 18%
Sheaffer Ballpoint Pen Refill "K" Style - Blue - Medium

Sheaffer Ballpoint Pen Refill "K" Style - Blue - Medium

Regular price $6.95
Sale price $6.95 Regular price
Sheaffer Ballpoint Pen Refill "K" Style - Black - Medium

Sheaffer Ballpoint Pen Refill "K" Style - Black - Medium

Regular price $6.95
Sale price $6.95 Regular price
Sheaffer Ballpoint Pen Refill "K" Style - Black - Fine

Sheaffer Ballpoint Pen Refill "K" Style - Black - Fine

Regular price $6.95
Sale price $6.95 Regular price
Sheaffer Ballpoint Pen Refill "K" Style - Blue - Fine

Sheaffer Ballpoint Pen Refill "K" Style - Blue - Fine

Regular price $6.95
Sale price $6.95 Regular price
Filofax Personal Transparent Envelope Top Opening

Filofax Personal Transparent Envelope Top Opening

Regular price $6.70
Sale price $6.70 Regular price
Filofax Personal Ruled White Notepaper Refills - 30 Sheets

Filofax Personal Ruled White Notepaper Refills - 30 Sheets

Regular price $6.60
Sale price $6.60 Regular price
Filofax Personal Dotted White Journal Refill - 30 Sheets

Filofax Personal Dotted White Journal Refill - 30 Sheets

Regular price $6.60
Sale price $6.60 Regular price
Filofax Personal Password Paper Refill Sheets

Filofax Personal Password Paper Refill Sheets

Regular price $6.60
Sale price $6.60 Regular price
Filofax Personal To Do Refill Sheets

Filofax Personal To Do Refill Sheets

Regular price $6.60
Sale price $6.60 Regular price
Filofax Personal White Contact Sheets - 20 Sheets

Filofax Personal White Contact Sheets - 20 Sheets

Regular price $6.60
Sale price $6.60 Regular price
Lamy Z27 Fountain Pen Converter

Lamy Z27 Fountain Pen Converter

Regular price $6.00
Sale price $6.00 Regular price
Lamy Z28 Fountain Pen Converter

Lamy Z28 Fountain Pen Converter

Regular price $6.00
Sale price $6.00 Regular price
X17 A6 ElastiXs 4 Pack

X17 A6 ElastiXs 4 Pack

Regular price $6.00
Sale price $6.00 Regular price
Faber-Castell Basic Rollerball Pen Refill - Blue

Faber-Castell Basic Rollerball Pen Refill - Blue

Regular price $6.00
Sale price $6.00 Regular price
Faber-Castell Basic Rollerball Pen Refill - Black

Faber-Castell Basic Rollerball Pen Refill - Black

Regular price $6.00
Sale price $6.00 Regular price
Lamy Z18 Spare Eraser Tip

Lamy Z18 Spare Eraser Tip

Regular price $6.00
Sale price $6.00 Regular price
Lamy M16 Giant Ballpoint Pen Refill - Blue

Lamy M16 Giant Ballpoint Pen Refill - Blue

Regular price $6.00
Sale price $6.00 Regular price
Lamy M16 Giant Ballpoint Pen Refill - Black

Lamy M16 Giant Ballpoint Pen Refill - Black

Regular price $6.00
Sale price $6.00 Regular price
Leuchtturm1917 Pen Loop - Black

Leuchtturm1917 Pen Loop - Black

Regular price $5.95
Sale price $5.95 Regular price
Leuchtturm1917 Pen Loop - Navy

Leuchtturm1917 Pen Loop - Navy

Regular price $5.95
Sale price $5.95 Regular price
Leuchtturm1917 Pen Loop - Forest Green

Leuchtturm1917 Pen Loop - Forest Green

Regular price $5.95
Sale price $5.95 Regular price
Leuchtturm1917 Pen Loop - Dusty Rose

Leuchtturm1917 Pen Loop - Dusty Rose

Regular price $5.95
Sale price $5.95 Regular price
Filofax A5 Week on Two Pages 2026 Multilanguage with Appointments Refill

Filofax A5 Week on Two Pages 2026 Multilanguage with Appointments Refill

Regular price $5.75
Sale price $5.75 Regular price $23.00 Save 75%
Filofax A5 Week on One Page with Notes 2026 Refill

Filofax A5 Week on One Page with Notes 2026 Refill

Regular price $5.75
Sale price $5.75 Regular price $23.00 Save 75%
Lamy M66 Rollerball Pen Refill - Red

Lamy M66 Rollerball Pen Refill - Red

Regular price $5.50
Sale price $5.50 Regular price
Lamy M66 Rollerball Pen Refill - Blue

Lamy M66 Rollerball Pen Refill - Blue

Regular price $5.50
Sale price $5.50 Regular price
Lamy M21 Ballpoint Pen Refill 2 Pack - Blue

Lamy M21 Ballpoint Pen Refill 2 Pack - Blue

Regular price $5.50
Sale price $5.50 Regular price $0.00
Lamy M21 Ballpoint Pen Refill 2 Pack - Black

Lamy M21 Ballpoint Pen Refill 2 Pack - Black

Regular price $5.50
Sale price $5.50 Regular price
Faber-Castell Ballpoint Pen Refill - Blue

Faber-Castell Ballpoint Pen Refill - Blue

Regular price $6.00
Sale price $6.00 Regular price
Faber-Castell Ballpoint Pen Refill - Black

Faber-Castell Ballpoint Pen Refill - Black

Regular price $6.00
Sale price $6.00 Regular price
Lamy M21 Ballpoint Pen Refill 2 Pack - Red

Lamy M21 Ballpoint Pen Refill 2 Pack - Red

Regular price $5.50
Sale price $5.50 Regular price