Skip to content

Welcome to the new Fahrney's Pens! ✍️

As we elevate the new experience, we continue to enhance products and brand selections.

If a link has moved or a favorite item is missing, our search bar may find it for you.

Planning Your Holiday Shopping?  See Our Holiday Shipping Details for Important Deadlines, Delivery Options, and Holiday Closures.

Planning Your Holiday Shopping?

See Our Holiday Shipping Details for Important Deadlines, Delivery Options, and Holiday Closures.

Collection: Gifts Under $250

Compare (0/6)

1070 products

Sheaffer Legacy Glossy Black Rollerball Pen with Chrome-Plated Trim

Sheaffer Legacy Glossy Black Rollerball Pen with Chrome-Plated Trim

Regular price $128.00
Sale price $128.00 Regular price $160.00 Save 20%
Ferris Wheel Press Masque Fountain Pen - The Twilight Symphony Limited Edition 2026

Ferris Wheel Press Masque Fountain Pen - The Twilight Symphony Limited Edition 2026

Regular price $125.00
Sale price $125.00 Regular price
Monteverde Ritma Brushed Stainless Steel 3+2 Piece Set

Monteverde Ritma Brushed Stainless Steel 3+2 Piece Set

Regular price $120.00
Sale price $120.00 Regular price $150.00 Save 20%
Monteverde Ritma Turquoise 3+2 Piece Set

Monteverde Ritma Turquoise 3+2 Piece Set

Regular price $120.00
Sale price $120.00 Regular price $150.00 Save 20%
Monteverde Ritma Purple 3+2 Piece Set

Monteverde Ritma Purple 3+2 Piece Set

Regular price $120.00
Sale price $120.00 Regular price $150.00 Save 20%
Monteverde Ritma Blue 3+2 Piece Set

Monteverde Ritma Blue 3+2 Piece Set

Regular price $120.00
Sale price $120.00 Regular price $150.00 Save 20%
Monteverde Ritma Black 3+2 Piece Set

Monteverde Ritma Black 3+2 Piece Set

Regular price $120.00
Sale price $120.00 Regular price $150.00 Save 20%
Cross ATX Cherry Blossom Polished Chrome Rollerball Pen

Cross ATX Cherry Blossom Polished Chrome Rollerball Pen

Regular price $120.00
Sale price $120.00 Regular price
Sheaffer Balance III Black Ballpoint Pen with Chrome Trim
New

Sheaffer Balance III Black Ballpoint Pen with Chrome Trim

Regular price $120.00
Sale price $120.00 Regular price $150.00 Save 20%
Filofax Finsbury Pocket Leather Organizer - Black

Filofax Finsbury Pocket Leather Organizer - Black

Regular price $120.00
Sale price $120.00 Regular price $150.00 Save 20%
Esterbrook Nook 6 Slot Pen Case - Moss Green

Esterbrook Nook 6 Slot Pen Case - Moss Green

Regular price $120.00
Sale price $120.00 Regular price
Esterbrook Nook 6 Slot Pen Case - Dandelion Blue

Esterbrook Nook 6 Slot Pen Case - Dandelion Blue

Regular price $120.00
Sale price $120.00 Regular price
Sheaffer Legacy Glossy Black Ballpoint Pen with Chrome-Plated Trim

Sheaffer Legacy Glossy Black Ballpoint Pen with Chrome-Plated Trim

Regular price $120.00
Sale price $120.00 Regular price $150.00 Save 20%
Cross ATX Sandblasted Titanium Gray Fountain Pen with Etched Diamond Pattern

Cross ATX Sandblasted Titanium Gray Fountain Pen with Etched Diamond Pattern

Regular price $120.00
Sale price $120.00 Regular price $150.00 Save 20%
Monteverde Special Edition Ritma Midnight Orchid 3+2 Set

Monteverde Special Edition Ritma Midnight Orchid 3+2 Set

Regular price $120.00
Sale price $120.00 Regular price $150.00 Save 20%
Tornado™ Stealth - Blue Black Fountain Pen

Retro51 Tornado™ Stealth Blue Black Fountain Pen

Regular price $118.00
Sale price $118.00 Regular price $118.00
Monteverde Innova Ti Solid Titanium Numbered Edition Fountain Pen

Monteverde Innova Ti Solid Titanium Numbered Edition Fountain Pen

Regular price $116.00
Sale price $116.00 Regular price $145.00 Save 20%
Conklin Professional Series Fountain Pen Lex/Lawyer

Conklin Professional Series Fountain Pen Lex/Lawyer

Regular price $116.00
Sale price $116.00 Regular price $145.00 Save 20%
Cross ATX Translucent Blue Lacquer Fountain Pen with Chrome Trim

Cross ATX Translucent Blue Lacquer Fountain Pen with Chrome Trim

Regular price $116.00
Sale price $116.00 Regular price $145.00 Save 20%
Cross ATX Brushed Rose Gold Rollerball Pen

Cross ATX Brushed Rose Gold Rollerball Pen

Regular price $115.00
Sale price $115.00 Regular price
Sheaffer Legacy Glossy Black & Chrome Ballpoint Pen with 14k PVD Gold-Plated Trim

Sheaffer Legacy Glossy Black & Chrome Ballpoint Pen with 14k PVD Gold-Plated Trim

Regular price $112.00
Sale price $112.00 Regular price $140.00 Save 20%
Cross ATX Cherry Blossom Polished Chrome Ballpoint Pen

Cross ATX Cherry Blossom Polished Chrome Ballpoint Pen

Regular price $110.00
Sale price $110.00 Regular price
Retro51 First Noel 2022 Fahrney's Exclusive Tornado™ Rollerball Pen

Retro51 First Noel 2022 Fahrney's Exclusive Tornado™ Rollerball Pen

Regular price $110.00
Sale price $110.00 Regular price
Sheaffer Emily in Paris Sentinel Pink Matte Ballpoint Pen with Chrome Trim & Full-Grain Leather Credit Card Holder Gift Set
Monteverde Innova Ti Solid Titanium Numbered Edition Rollerball Pen

Monteverde Innova Ti Solid Titanium Numbered Edition Rollerball Pen

Regular price $108.00
Sale price $108.00 Regular price $135.00 Save 20%
Waterman Hemisphere Fountain Pen Black Gold Trim

Waterman Hemisphere Fountain Pen Black Gold Trim

Regular price $106.40
Sale price $106.40 Regular price $132.97 Save 20%
Conklin Endura Deco Crest Fountain Pen - Orange

Conklin Endura Deco Crest Fountain Pen - Orange

Regular price $125.00
Sale price $125.00 Regular price
Esterbrook Estie Sea Glass Ballpoint Pen - Chrome Trim

Esterbrook Estie Sea Glass Ballpoint Pen - Chrome Trim

Regular price $125.00
Sale price $125.00 Regular price
Gravitas Pocket Full White Delrin Fountain Pen

Gravitas Pocket Full White Delrin Fountain Pen

Regular price $120.00
Sale price $120.00 Regular price
Parker Sonnet Matte Black Ballpoint Pen with Gold Trim

Parker Sonnet Matte Black Ballpoint Pen with Gold Trim

Regular price $114.24
Sale price $114.24 Regular price $142.80 Save 20%
Set of pens in a black case on a white background

Aston Leather Zippered 40 Pen Case - Black

Regular price $112.00
Sale price $112.00 Regular price $140.00 Save 20%
Waterman Hemisphere Metallic Stone Grey Rollerball Pen with Gold Trim

Waterman Hemisphere Metallic Stone Grey Rollerball Pen with Gold Trim

Regular price $108.00
Sale price $108.00 Regular price $135.00 Save 20%