Skip to content

Welcome to the new Fahrney's Pens! ✍️

As we elevate the new experience, we continue to enhance products and brand selections.

If a link has moved or a favorite item is missing, our search bar may find it for you.

Planning Your Holiday Shopping?  See Our Holiday Shipping Details for Important Deadlines, Delivery Options, and Holiday Closures.

Planning Your Holiday Shopping?

See Our Holiday Shipping Details for Important Deadlines, Delivery Options, and Holiday Closures.

Collection: Gifts Under $500

Compare (0/6)

1136 products

Esterbrook Raven Niblet Fountain Pen

Esterbrook Raven Niblet Fountain Pen

Regular price $157.50
Sale price $157.50 Regular price $175.00 Save 10%
Esterbrook Honeycomb Niblet Fountain Pen

Esterbrook Honeycomb Niblet Fountain Pen

Regular price $157.50
Sale price $157.50 Regular price $175.00 Save 10%
Esterbrook JR Twinkle Limited Edition Fountain Pen

Esterbrook JR Twinkle Limited Edition Fountain Pen

Regular price $157.50
Sale price $157.50 Regular price $175.00 Save 10%
Esterbrook JR Fantasia Limited Edition Fountain Pen

Esterbrook JR Fantasia Limited Edition Fountain Pen

Regular price $157.50
Sale price $157.50 Regular price $175.00 Save 10%
Sheaffer Balance III Black Rollerball Pen with Gold Trim
New

Sheaffer Balance III Black Rollerball Pen with Gold Trim

Regular price $152.00
Sale price $152.00 Regular price $190.00 Save 20%
Sheaffer Legacy Chevron Black Rollerball Pen

Sheaffer Legacy Chevron Black Rollerball Pen

Regular price $152.00
Sale price $152.00 Regular price $190.00 Save 20%
Faber-Castell Ambition All Black Fountain Pen

Faber-Castell Ambition All Black Fountain Pen

Regular price $152.00
Sale price $152.00 Regular price
Cross ATX Brushed Black Fountain Pen with Black PVD Trim

Cross ATX Brushed Black Fountain Pen with Black PVD Trim

Regular price $150.00
Sale price $150.00 Regular price
Kaweco Supra Fountain Pen - Black

Kaweco Supra Fountain Pen - Black

Regular price $150.00
Sale price $150.00 Regular price
Cross Century II Black Lacquer Ballpoint Pen with 23K Gold-Plated Trim

Cross Century II Black Lacquer Ballpoint Pen with 23K Gold-Plated Trim

Regular price $145.00
Sale price $145.00 Regular price
Parker Sonnet Matte Black Rollerball Pen - Chrome Trim

Parker Sonnet Matte Black Rollerball Pen - Chrome Trim

Regular price $144.08
Sale price $144.08 Regular price $180.10 Save 20%
Monteverde Ritma Walnut 3+2 Piece Set

Monteverde Ritma Walnut 3+2 Piece Set

Regular price $144.00
Sale price $144.00 Regular price $180.00 Save 20%
Cross ATX Cherry Blossom Polished Chrome Fountain Pen

Cross ATX Cherry Blossom Polished Chrome Fountain Pen

Regular price $140.00
Sale price $140.00 Regular price
Sheaffer Balance III Black Rollerball Pen with Chrome Trim
New

Sheaffer Balance III Black Rollerball Pen with Chrome Trim

Regular price $140.00
Sale price $140.00 Regular price $175.00 Save 20%
Diplomat Cobra Burgundy Red Guilloche Fountain Pen
New

Diplomat Cobra Burgundy Red Guilloche Fountain Pen

Regular price $140.00
Sale price $140.00 Regular price $175.00 Save 20%
Diplomat Cobra Matte Black Guilloche Fountain Pen
New

Diplomat Cobra Matte Black Guilloche Fountain Pen

Regular price $140.00
Sale price $140.00 Regular price $175.00 Save 20%
Esterbrook Nook 12 Slot Pen Case - Moss Green

Esterbrook Nook 12 Slot Pen Case - Moss Green

Regular price $140.00
Sale price $140.00 Regular price
Esterbrook Nook 12 Slot Pen Case - Dandelion Blue

Esterbrook Nook 12 Slot Pen Case - Dandelion Blue

Regular price $140.00
Sale price $140.00 Regular price
Cross ATX Sandblasted Dark Blue Fountain Pen with Etched Diamond Pattern

Cross ATX Sandblasted Dark Blue Fountain Pen with Etched Diamond Pattern

Regular price From $140.00
Sale price From $140.00 Regular price
Retro51 2026 Cherry Blossom Fahrney's Exclusive Tornado™ Fountain Pen
New

Retro51 2026 Cherry Blossom Fahrney's Exclusive Tornado™ Fountain Pen

Regular price $139.50
Sale price $139.50 Regular price $139.50
Sheaffer 100 Emily in Paris Champagne Gold Ballpoint Pen & Full-Grain Credit Card Holder Gift Set

Sheaffer 100 Emily in Paris Champagne Gold Ballpoint Pen & Full-Grain Credit Card Holder Gift Set

Regular price $134.95
Sale price $134.95 Regular price
Diplomat Cobra Burgundy Red Guilloche Rollerball Pen
New

Diplomat Cobra Burgundy Red Guilloche Rollerball Pen

Regular price $132.00
Sale price $132.00 Regular price $165.00 Save 20%
Diplomat Cobra Matte Black Guilloche Rollerball Pen
New

Diplomat Cobra Matte Black Guilloche Rollerball Pen

Regular price $132.00
Sale price $132.00 Regular price $165.00 Save 20%
Diamine Inkvent 2026 Calendar - Burgundy Edition - 25 Ink Set
New

Diamine Inkvent 2026 Calendar - Burgundy Edition - 25 Ink Set

Regular price $130.00
Sale price $130.00 Regular price
Conklin Mark Twain Crescent Filler Orange Medley Fountain Pen

Conklin Mark Twain Crescent Filler Orange Medley Fountain Pen

Regular price $156.00
Sale price $156.00 Regular price $195.00 Save 20%
Product coming soon

Waterman Expert Rollerball Pen - Black with Chrome Trim

Regular price $148.80
Sale price $148.80 Regular price $186.00 Save 20%
Product coming soon

Parker Sonnet Matte Black Ballpoint Pen with Chrome Trim

Regular price $142.80
Sale price $142.80 Regular price
Faber-Castell Ambition Italic Ice Blue Fountain Pen

Faber-Castell Ambition Italic Ice Blue Fountain Pen

Regular price $140.00
Sale price $140.00 Regular price
Monteverde Limited Edition Innova 250th Anniversary Rollerball Pen

Monteverde Limited Edition Innova 250th Anniversary Rollerball Pen

Regular price $132.00
Sale price $132.00 Regular price $165.00 Save 20%
Conklin 1898 Limited Edition Spectra Fusion White Fountain Pen

Conklin 1898 Limited Edition Spectra Fusion White Fountain Pen

Regular price $132.00
Sale price $132.00 Regular price $165.00 Save 20%
Conklin 1898 Limited Edition Spectra Fusion Blue Fountain Pen

Conklin 1898 Limited Edition Spectra Fusion Blue Fountain Pen

Regular price $132.00
Sale price $132.00 Regular price $165.00 Save 20%
Filofax Saffiano A5 Organizer - Modular - Dark Cherry

Filofax Saffiano A5 Organizer - Modular - Dark Cherry

Regular price $130.00
Sale price $130.00 Regular price $0.00